param noise_seed limit ?

[martinjonesbe]

Hello,

When I use a workflow in Comfy Workflow with the Xlabs sampler, I can generate an image without any issue using the seed 325649530239079.
However, when I import the same workflow into the "Generate" tab, I get an error message saying that noise_seed cannot exceed 9999999999.

Why is there such a limitation, when Comfy itself doesn't seem to impose this restriction?
Is there a setting somewhere in SwarmUI that allows changing this limit?

Thanks in advance!

[mcmonkey4eva]

I've pushed an update that should trim giant seeds to prevent the error (it will just cut a few digits off the end of the seed).

The reason it's an issue is that sampler has a max noise_seed value of 2^64, which is a giant number that's janky to properly represent. Most software handling of numbers caps at 2^63 unless you used advanced large-width number handling, which... would be very silly to integrate, vs just capping seeds to saner limits. the 9999999999 value is approx 2^33, ie it's a limit exceeding what any standard int32 randomizer can pick.