Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
104 lines (69 loc) · 6.95 KB

5_heap_problem.md

File metadata and controls

104 lines (69 loc) · 6.95 KB
Raw

Problem Statement 📘

  1. Heap Memory Region and Its Expansion:

    • When a program claims memory (e.g., 20 bytes) using the malloc function, the heap region expands accordingly.
    • The starting address of this allocated memory block is saved in a pointer variable (e.g., P1).

  2. Memory Claiming:

    • As the process claims more memory through subsequent malloc calls, the heap memory region continuously expands from a lower to a higher address.
    • Different memory blocks of varied sizes (e.g., 10 bytes, 15 bytes, etc.) can be claimed and each would have its corresponding pointer (e.g., P2, P3).

  3. The Free Function:

    • free is called with a pointer (e.g., P3) to release memory.
    • However, the free function is not passed the size of the memory to be freed, which raises questions about how the operating system determines the amount of memory to release.

  4. Operating System’s Memory Management:

    • The OS must keep track of each
      • malloc call and the
      • corresponding byte size allocated to manage memory appropriately.
    • It needs to ensure that the memory blocks organized and associated accurately with their respective pointers and sizes (e.g., P3 is associated with a 10-byte block).

  5. Validation of Memory Addresses:

    • The OS should verify that addresses passed to free are valid and were returned by a previous malloc or calloc call to avoid freeing random, invalid, or critical memory addresses.

🧐 Curiosity

  1. Memory Allocation Management:

    • Q: How does the operating system keep track of each allocated memory block size since malloc does not pass the size during a free call?
    • A: The OS typically maintains a data structure or a management block that stores metadata about each allocated block, including its size, so that it can manage memory allocations and deallocations accurately.

  2. Memory Block Organization:

    • Q: How does the operating system organize and manage multiple memory blocks assigned by malloc?
    • A: It often uses a memory allocation table or a similar data structure to keep track of all active memory blocks, their sizes, and starting addresses, ensuring they are managed and freed correctly.

  3. Memory Address Validation:

    • Q: How does the OS ensure that a memory address passed to the free function is valid and was previously allocated by malloc or calloc?
    • A: It typically checks against its memory management data structures to validate whether the provided address corresponds to a previously allocated block and whether it is a legitimate address to be freed.

  4. Efficiency in Memory Management:

    • Q: How does the operating system ensure efficient memory management to avoid fragmentation and wastage in the heap memory region?
    • A: Through memory management algorithms, like best-fit, worst-fit, or first-fit, the OS tries to allocate memory in a way that minimizes fragmentation and optimizes usage.

  5. Handling Invalid Free Calls:

    • Q: What happens if an invalid address or a non-malloced/calloced address is passed to free?
    • A: It usually results in undefined behavior, which might include program crashes, data corruption, or other unreliable outcomes.

🗣️ Concepts in Simple Words

  • Heap Memory: Think of heap memory like a chunk of space where your program can ask for a piece to store some data. When it asks for space using malloc, the heap gives a portion and marks that part as taken.

  • Using Malloc and Free: malloc is like telling the heap, "I need this much space," and the heap gives a pointer (address) to use that space. When done, free tells the heap, "I'm done with this space," so it can be used again.

  • Operating System's Role: The operating system is like the manager of this space, making sure each program gets its asked space and ensures no two programs use the same spot unless it's freed. It remembers how much space was given to each request (using some internal record-keeping) so that when free is called, it knows how much space to free up, even though we just give it the starting address.

  • Being Safe with Memory: It’s important that the addresses given to free were once provided by malloc, to make sure we don’t accidentally ask the heap to clear out important or wrong areas. So, the operating system has to double-check this to keep things running smoothly and avoid errors or crashes.

Diagram to represent how the heap memory allocation and freeing process, as explained in the given problem statement, works.

+--------------------- Heap Memory ---------------------+
|  P1 (20 bytes)   |  P2 (10 bytes)  | P3 (10 bytes)   | P4 (15 bytes) | P5 (20 bytes) |
+-------------------+-----------------+-----------------+---------------+--------------+

    |                    |                  |                  |                   |
    V                    V                  V                  V                   V
 20 bytes             10 bytes           10 bytes           15 bytes            20 bytes

Allocated           Allocated          Allocated          Allocated           Allocated
Memory Blocks       Memory Blocks      Memory Blocks      Memory Blocks       Memory Blocks

Explanation:

  • Each section P1, P2, P3, P4, and P5 represents a block of heap memory allocated using malloc. The number within the parenthesis represents the number of bytes allocated for each block.

  • Each V arrow represents the pointer variables (like P1, P2, etc.) pointing towards the allocated memory block.

Memory Freeing Scenario:

+--------------------- Heap Memory ---------------------+
|  P1 (20 bytes)   |  P2 (10 bytes)  | xxxxxxxxxx   | P4 (15 bytes) | P5 (20 bytes) |
+-------------------+-----------------+-----------------+---------------+--------------+

    |                    |                 X                  |                   |
    V                    V                                    V                   V
 20 bytes             10 bytes                             15 bytes            20 bytes

Allocated           Allocated                              Allocated           Allocated
Memory Blocks       Memory Blocks                          Memory Blocks       Memory Blocks

Explanation:

  • When free(P3) is called, the 10 bytes of memory that P3 was pointing to gets deallocated (represented by xxxxxxxxxx), and the arrow X is crossed out, indicating that the pointer P3 is no longer valid or has been set to NULL.

Notes:

  • P1, P2, etc.: Pointer variables which store the starting address of the memory blocks allocated by malloc.

  • xxxxxxxxxx: Represents memory that has been freed using free().

This simple ASCII diagram illustrates how memory is allocated and freed in the heap memory region. When memory is allocated, it's represented by sections with the pointer variable and size. When it's freed, the memory region is denoted with xs to showcase that it's no longer in use.