X11 builds with native compilation don't work

[chetstone]

Builds OK with brew install emacs-plus@28 --with-x11 --with-retro-sink-bw-icon --with-native-comp but when run it fails with the same error message as #333:

emacs: can't find function "F6d656e752d6261722d7570646174652d62756666657273_menu_bar_update_buffers_0" in compilation unit /usr/local/Cellar/emacs-plus@28/28.0.50/libexec/emacs/28.0.50/x86_64-apple-darwin20.4.0/../../../../bin/../lib/emacs/28.0.50/native-lisp/28.0.50-790491c2/preloaded/menu-bar-4f46ea94-bb2650c8.eln

I've tried pinning the build to known good commits, including 3f8b303 and f4dc646e0d7fb673f3149836bb7299fba9539e80, which I used to build a cocoa version with native compilation about 10 days ago and has been working well. All fail with the same error.

The X11 builds work fine if --with-native-comp is not used.

[d12frosted]

Seems like something is wrong with menu bar. I also see it in #361

f4dc646e0d7fb673f3149836bb7299fba9539e80, which I used to build a cocoa version with native compilation about 10 days ago and has been working well. All fail with the same error.

Sorry, didn't understand. Doesn't that mean that f4dc646e0d7fb673f3149836bb7299fba9539e80 is used to work, but is not working anymore? Did you update macos in those 10 days?

I am using a pretty old macbooks (2014 and 2009), so don't have this issue.

[chetstone]

No, f4dc646e0d7fb673f3149836bb7299fba9539e80 works well when built with cocoa and native compilation. I've been using it for a couple of weeks.

But it's one of several commits I used to try to build with X11 and native compilation, and none of them worked--- all failed with the same error.

[thinkiny]

Same issue here，i use brew install emacs-plus@28 --with-xwidgets --with-modern-cg433n-icon --with-native-comp

[mkvoya]

Same issue here, too. This issue seems to be the same as #364 .
In the output of objdump -D menu-bar-4f46ea94-7781c24c.eln, I can see a function named _F6d656e752d6261722d7570646174652d62756666657273_menu_bar_update_buffers_0. Note the leading underscore. I doubt the issue is caused by the extra leading underscore.

[d12frosted]

Should be fixed via 4f44f33. Please verify.