You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
This is not some weird interaction with other data like osmandapp/OsmAnd#13543: to be completely sure of avoiding such issues, I've changed my workflow to use a separate installation of OsmAnd with no OBF files installed except the one I'm testing.
AFAICT, the problem is simply that OsmAndMapCreator isn't smart enough to exclude POIs that JOSM has marked as action='delete'. (I didn't test whether this affects other kinds of objects as well.) Please consider adding this feature to facilitate testing changes before upload. Or let me know if there is a different process I should be following to test my changes in OsmAnd that avoids the problem.
A workaround is to make a copy of the OSM file with action='delete' objects removed before running OsmAndMapCreator. I edited the objects out manually, but it could probably be automated if it's worth the work, via XSLT if not some OpenStreetMap-specific tool.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I generally prepare my OSM changes using JOSM and test them before upload by loading a custom OBF file into OsmAnd; I documented the process at https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Testing_changes_before_upload#OsmAnd. Today, I made a change that deleted a POI, but the POI still appeared in OsmAnd during my test. I saw the problem with
OsmAndMapCreator-main.zip
as of today (2022-12-30). Here are example OSM and OBF files that demonstrate the problem.This is not some weird interaction with other data like osmandapp/OsmAnd#13543: to be completely sure of avoiding such issues, I've changed my workflow to use a separate installation of OsmAnd with no OBF files installed except the one I'm testing.
AFAICT, the problem is simply that OsmAndMapCreator isn't smart enough to exclude POIs that JOSM has marked as
action='delete'
. (I didn't test whether this affects other kinds of objects as well.) Please consider adding this feature to facilitate testing changes before upload. Or let me know if there is a different process I should be following to test my changes in OsmAnd that avoids the problem.A workaround is to make a copy of the OSM file with
action='delete'
objects removed before running OsmAndMapCreator. I edited the objects out manually, but it could probably be automated if it's worth the work, via XSLT if not some OpenStreetMap-specific tool.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: