PHP FTP Extension

[aarongerig]

Was this extension removed intentionally? Before when using pimcore/pimcore:PHP8.2-fpm the FTP extension was enabled, with pimcore/pimcore:php8.3-latest this is no longer the case. If not, would you be open to re-add it?

[brusch]

@aarongerig actually we only enable extensions that are either required by Pimcore (min flavour) or used by optional features (max flavour). We also have the default as the recommended image.
AFAIK FTP isn't used at all by Pimcore, that's why it's not included, or I'm wrong?

[jdreesen]

Also, it shouldn't be a problem to extend the image and add it yourself, should it?

[aarongerig]

@brusch I see – no you're absolutely right, Pimcore does not use FTP and/or XSL in its core. There are some community extensions that require it though and that used to work with the older Pimcore Docker images (e.g. pimcore/pimcore:PHP8.2-fpm) out-of-the-box. That's why I assumed that it was maybe removed unintentionally... 😅

Example XSL: Pimcore Emailizr > Twig Inky Extra > Pinky

But I'm fine with extending the image, as @jdreesen suggested. I'm going to close both issues on that regard.
Thanks for the info!

[jdreesen]

Apparently it was not removed here, but in the official PHP image, see: docker-library/php#1488