gorilla mux not working with twirp handler

[barthr]

I was trying twirp today to add some calls to an existing service which uses the gorilla mux (https://github.com/gorilla/mux). But the handler from twirp wasn't working with the mux from gorilla. Is this intentional or something we could support in the future?

The mux from gorilla implements the http.Handler interface and also the Handle method for registring a http.Handler with a specific path.

[spenczar]

This should work without much trouble. Like so:

svc := example.NewHaberdasherServer(...)

r := mux.NewRouter()
r.PathPrefix(example.HaberdasherPathPrefix).Handler(svc)

Could you post the code that isn't working for you?

[marioizquierdo]

Twirp services can only be mounted on the root path. See, the generated service router works on the req.URL.Path

twirp/example/service.twirp.go

Line 156 in dff337b

switch req.URL.Path {

it looks for an exact match, independently of where it was mounted. Maybe this is the issue?

[barthr]

Ahh I see. Didn't notice that, I was defining it like this:

svc := example.NewHaberdasherServer(...)

r := mux.NewRouter()
r.Handle(example.HaberdasherPathPrefix, svc)

Mental note, always mount it on the root path with PathPrefix Thanks!

[spenczar]

Right, github.com/gorilla/mux uses r.Handle as an exact match, not a prefix match.