diff --git a/style.css b/style.css
index e53fc8818..60352e62b 100644
--- a/style.css
+++ b/style.css
@@ -376,7 +376,7 @@ ul {
   text-decoration: none;
 }
 
-.button.button-primary:hover, .split-button button.button-primary:hover, .section-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .section-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .article-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .article-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .community-follow button.button-primary:hover, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .subscriptions-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .subscriptions-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .button-primary.pagination-next-link:hover, .button-primary.pagination-prev-link:hover, .button-primary.pagination-first-link:hover, .button-primary.pagination-last-link:hover, .button.button-primary:focus, .split-button button.button-primary:focus, .section-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .section-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .article-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .article-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .community-follow button.button-primary:focus, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .subscriptions-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .subscriptions-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .button-primary.pagination-next-link:focus, .button-primary.pagination-prev-link:focus, .button-primary.pagination-first-link:focus, .button-primary.pagination-last-link:focus, .button.button-primary:active, .split-button button.button-primary:active, .section-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .section-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .article-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .article-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .community-follow button.button-primary:active, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .subscriptions-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .subscriptions-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .button-primary.pagination-next-link:active, .button-primary.pagination-prev-link:active, .button-primary.pagination-first-link:active, .button-primary.pagination-last-link:active {
+.button.button-primary:hover, .split-button button:hover, .section-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .section-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .article-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .article-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .community-follow button.button-primary:hover, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .subscriptions-subscribe button.button-primary:hover, .subscriptions-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:hover, .button-primary.pagination-next-link:hover, .button-primary.pagination-prev-link:hover, .button-primary.pagination-first-link:hover, .button-primary.pagination-last-link:hover, .button.button-primary:focus, .split-button button.button-primary:focus, .section-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .section-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .article-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .article-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .community-follow button.button-primary:focus, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .subscriptions-subscribe button.button-primary:focus, .subscriptions-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:focus, .button-primary.pagination-next-link:focus, .button-primary.pagination-prev-link:focus, .button-primary.pagination-first-link:focus, .button-primary.pagination-last-link:focus, .button.button-primary:active, .split-button button.button-primary:active, .section-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .section-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .article-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .article-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .community-follow button.button-primary:active, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .requests-table-toolbar .organization-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .subscriptions-subscribe button.button-primary:active, .subscriptions-subscribe button[data-selected="true"]:active, .button-primary.pagination-next-link:active, .button-primary.pagination-prev-link:active, .button-primary.pagination-first-link:active, .button-primary.pagination-last-link:active {
   background-color: darken($brand_color, 20%);
   border-color: darken($brand_color, 20%);
 }
@@ -434,9 +434,9 @@ ul {
   background-color: $brand_color;
   border: 0;
   color: $brand_text_color;
-  line-height: normal;
+  height: 32px;
+  line-height: 16px;
   outline-color: $brand_color;
-  padding: 8px 20px;
 }
 
 [dir="rtl"] .split-button button:not(:only-child):first-child {
@@ -452,6 +452,9 @@ ul {
 }
 
 .split-button button:not(:only-child):last-child {
+  display: flex;
+  justify-content: center;
+  align-items: center;
   width: 26px;
   min-width: 26px;
   max-width: 26px;
diff --git a/styles/_split_button.scss b/styles/_split_button.scss
index e37d54941..8bcf9b44d 100644
--- a/styles/_split_button.scss
+++ b/styles/_split_button.scss
@@ -3,14 +3,18 @@
   display: flex;
 }
 
+.split-button button:hover {
+  @extend .button-primary:hover;
+}
+
 .split-button button {
   @extend .button;
   background-color: $brand_color;
   border: 0;
   color: $brand_text_color;
-  line-height: normal;
+  height: 32px;
+  line-height: 16px;
   outline-color: $brand_color;
-  padding: 8px 20px;
 }
 
 .split-button button:not(:only-child) {
@@ -29,6 +33,9 @@
   }
 
   &:last-child {
+    display: flex;
+    justify-content: center;
+    align-items: center;
     width: 26px;
     min-width: 26px;
     max-width: 26px;