Skip to content

Codeblocks from P2286R8 need a home #5719

Closed
@burblebee

Description

@burblebee

P2286R8 Formatting Ranges #5700 introduced several codeblocks that appear in the middle of normative wording and aren't in a synopsis or itemdecl. The codeblocks contain definitions of formatter and range_formatter, and are listed below with their location within the spec followed by a line identifying what they define (note that these may have changed as the result of P2585R1 #5706 and/or other edits):

  • [vector.bool]/p8 struct formatter<T, charT> {
  • [assoc.format]/p1 struct formatter<@\placeholder{map-type}@<Key, T, U...>, charT> {
  • [assoc.format]/p5 struct formatter<@\placeholder{set-type}@<Key, U...>, charT> {
  • [container.adaptors.format]/p1 struct formatter<@\placeholder{adaptor-type}@<T, Container, U...>, charT> {
  • [format.range.formatter]/p6 class range_formatter {
  • [format.range.formatter]/p12 struct formatter<R, charT> {
  • [format.tuple]/p1 struct formatter<@\placeholder{pair-or-tuple}@<Ts...>, charT> {

A proposal for how to resolve the 1st case follows:
Split the [vector.bool] subclause into [vector.bool.general] containing paras 1-3, and [vector.bool.ref] containing paras 4-6 and the is-vector-bool-reference variable template. We need to find somewhere for hash<vector<bool, Allocator>>, maybe after para 3 in [vector.bool.general]. Then the formatter specialization and its members can be in [vector.bool.formatter].
Originally posted by @jwakely in #5700 (comment)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions