DMN14-190/DMN14-191/DMN14-192/DMN14-193/DMN14-194/DMN14-195 Changes to the diagrams for conditional, filter and iterator boxed expression

[SimonRinguette]

Related to XSD changes #14, #15 & #16
MM change #18

[falko]

Approved in Ballot 5

[falko]

@SimonRinguette after discusing and reviewing DMN14-195 with Michelle, I noticed that the proposal text also mentioned adding the following to Figure 10.17 Expression class diagram:

Add the following abstract class extending Expression

Iterator
+iteratorVariable: String

Add the following class extending Iterator

For

Add the following abstract class extending Iterator

Quantified

Add the following class extending Quantified

Every

Add the following class extending Quantified

Some

Add the following class

ChildExpression
+id: ID [0..1]

Add the following class extending ChildExpression

TypedChildExpression
+typeRef: String [0..1]

Create one aggregation between ChildExpression and
Expression named value with a cardinality of 1.

Create an aggregation between Iterator and the new
TypedChildExpression class named “in” with a cardinality
of 1.

Create an aggregation between For and ChildExpression
named return with a cardinality of 1.

Create an aggregation between Quantified and
ChildExpression named satisfies with a cardinality of
1.

However the only addition to the diagram seems to be the class Iterator:

Am I missing something or should I raise this as an issue to complete the diagram in DMN 1.5?

[falko]

@sringuette any feedback regarding this?

[SimonRinguette]

In the metamodel, (magic draw) i've created an ExpressionL4 diagram with these details:

However, when doing the actual change, these details were not appropriate for the L3 diagram and would not fit on the real estate we had.

If we want these details in the diagram, you can raise an issue to have that diagram integrated in 1.5

[falko]

We discussed it in today's RTF meeting and are going to raise an issue to add the diagram in DMN 1.5 as you suggested.