-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.6k
New issue
Have a question about this project? # for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “#”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? # to your account
BSoD "CRITICAL_PROCESS_DIED" when terminate all sandboxed programs #1316
Comments
do you have a crash dump? |
I have encountered such a very rare BSOD, in one case was associated with kill of a single process through SandMan. I was not sure that this is not a hardware problem. |
It was happening for me every time I have tried to shutdown my laptop on Windows 10. Now I have Windows 11. Shutdown seems to work fine. I had only one BSOD but dump was not generated for some reason |
You can use this program to view: https://www.nirsoft.net/utils/blue_screen_view.html the main thing is to select the correct dump in the |
Windbg is better |
I receive memory management bsod when restarting the computer when Classic v5.51.6 in installed. However I can not be sure it is cause by sandboxie. Anyway, it is the fastest working version my slow pc with Windows 11. |
This comment was marked as outdated.
This comment was marked as outdated.
Throwing my hat into the ring too, I've experienced this twice since upgrading from 5.51.5 to 5.53.3, I don't know the cause, it seems pretty rare, but both times, when doing the "terminate all" thing, a BSOD happened. |
It happens every time I shut down my PC. However dump is never generated. It is enabled though. What's more, it does not seem to happen on restart. It did it on Windows 10 and it still does it after upgrading to Windows 11 |
There is a Windows glitch. If you manually select to use pagefile exclusively on systemdrive, it warns you that minidumps may not be generated at all. They are generated but somehow not saved. |
I also encountered this problem, it may be caused by SbieSvc.exe process. windbg_memorydump.txt 3: kd> !thread |
My apologies. i found out this BSOD was occurring due to Veracrypt issue and only at end of shutting down PC |
It looks like after the updates my problem was solved. |
@0x391F Does this still happen to you? |
No, I think. |
The issue occurred to me. BSOD 'CRITICAL_PROCESS_DIED' while terminating all sandboxed programs. I attach the minidump itself. I also attach the WinDbg output of both the minidump and the MEMORY.dmp: The latter reveals that the BSOD is caused by SbieSvc.exe process.
|
I can't reproduce it with current build v1.5.3 x64 - W10 21H2 x64 + W11 22H2 x64 (empty standard sandboxes). |
This bug reproduce today. I run VMware Workstation Pro (17.0.0 build-20800274) in sandbox and a VM is running, then delete contents without terminate all process manually, then BSoD "CRITICAL_PROCESS_DIED" happens. |
I had this bsod yesterday too on Hyper-V. |
@DavidXanatos Are there any findings here? Unfortunately, I also have a BSoD every few weeks (sometimes after months). It always happens when a main program (e.g. Firefox, Edge) is closed and therefore the sandbox is cleaned and closed. I guess it requires some special timing or something, since I haven't managed to reproduce it manually yet either. It is now also happened under the current version 1.8.0. Do you possibly need the memory dump? |
Do you use any AV or disk encryption software? I guess the dump or windbg analysis is always needed in such case |
Just Windows 10's Defender and no encryption software either. I'll send @DavidXanatos the crash/memory dumps if he wants them. |
yes please |
In the past few days I've had three BSOD crashes caused by the same issue, upon closing the last sandboxed program the crash occurs. Same configuration as listed here. I will try to downgrade to the previous Sandboxie release and report if there are any changes.
|
This bug reproduce yesterday, but unfortunately, crash dump has been disabled. |
Today, while trying to reproduce issue #4421 on a Windows 11 24H2 virtual machine, I encountered this BSOD once again. Bugcheck Analysis
|
To those who are affected by this issue, do you all have StartRunAlertDenied=y enabled? |
Thank you for your reply. No, “StartRunAlertDenied=y” is not enabled in the settings. |
Please try the next build 1.15.4 i have added a bunch of mitigations which may solve this issue |
Great news! Since the crash always occurs randomly and I still haven't found a way to reproducing or forcing it, it may take longer for a feedback. Thank you very much for taking a closer look at the issue. |
1.15.4 is released |
Describe the bug
BSoD "CRITICAL_PROCESS_DIED" when terminate all sandboxed programs.
To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:
System details and installed software
Windows 10 Enterprise LTSC 2019 x64
Sandboxie Plus 0.9.8 and Sandboxie 5.53.0 (64-bit)
If you have a compatibility issue
Additional context
Add any other context about the problem here.
Sandboxie configuration
If applicable, consider to attach your Sandboxie.ini configuration by copying the content on https://gist.github.com and sharing the resulting link. If you decide to paste the configuration here, make sure to use the backticks around strings, like in this working example:
My initial sandboxie.ini settings
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: